How close are we to having new stem cell therapies that work?
The field is nearly there on several fronts, but we shouldn’t get ahead of ourselves. Last week I noted the “soon” in a Nature News headline “Stem cells head to the clinic: treatments for cancer, diabetes and Parkinson’s disease could soon be here.” It seemed a little much to me.
We are definitely getting closer on some fronts and it’s exciting, but the final stretch often takes years longer than one might hope. In scrolling back to old posts here on The Niche, I often find the word “soon” in media pieces about stem cell therapies that I noted. Yet, in all those cases now 10 or even 14 years later, nothing has come of those investigational cell therapies in question. It’s easy to spark false hope.
Let’s start with another new piece that arguably got ahead of where things stand on stem cell therapies.
Stem cell therapies that work?
Stem-cell therapies that work: 10 Breakthrough Technologies 2025, MIT Tech Review. That definitive headline caught my eye. I would think in reading it that these therapies have FDA approval. Instead, the piece includes two still investigational stem cell therapies together as an item in a top 10 list of breakthrough technologies.
The piece highlights work from Neurona Therapeutics on its investigational epilepsy cell therapy and Vertex’s investigational diabetes cell therapy. They are both exciting, but these therapies have not actually been proven to work yet in groups of people.
It’s crucial to be at least somewhat cautious with N=1 (or even N=2, etc.)-type reports.
All this being said, one of my predictions for 2025 for the regenerative medicine field is that the FDA will approve at least one new regenerative therapy after its recent Mesoblast approval. It’s not just the science though. Politics will play a major role.
Other stem cell and regenerative reads
- Gliomagenesis mimics an injury response orchestrated by neural crest-like cells, Nature. This is from a team led by Peter B. Dirks
- Exosomes Are Being Hyped as a ‘Silver Bullet’ Therapy. Scientists Say No. Singularity Hub. I’ve written many times about exosomes including the current unproven state of exosome therapy.
- Bone marrow niches orchestrate stem-cell hierarchy and immune tolerance, Nature.
- The histone H3.3 K27M mutation suppresses Ser31phosphorylation and mitotic fidelity, which can directly drive gliomagenesis, Curr Bio. The Knoepfler Lab works on H3.3 K27M as well as the normal functions of H3.3 in brain development.
- Stem Cell Transplantation Still the Main Treatment Option for Beta-Thalassemia, MedPage Today.
- Joe Rogan reveals new injury after hunting issue, Newsweek. No shock that stem cells came up in this piece. Joe Rogan seems enamored of stem cells. Here they wrote: “After the trip, Rogan committed to addressing the damage. He underwent stem cell shots, intense stretching, foam rolling, and a combination of sauna and cold plunge sessions to aid his recovery.”
- Stem Cell Transplant Effective for Children With Arthritis, Medscape. This is a very intense HSCT-type procedure, not the kind of MSC offerings of unproven stem cell clinics, some of which market to children with various conditions including arthritis.
Blast from the past
This is only two years ago, but fits with the risks of false hope and the N=1 trap: Overplaying N=1 in the stem cell therapy world.